CO129-275 - Governor Sir Robinson - 1897 [1-5] — Page 555

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

The Colonial Government is not aware that such a right has ever been conferred. It is true that upon representation by the Military Authorities, the defence requirements of certain batteries rendered further building in certain localities most undesirable.

It may be contended that in agreeing to permit the erection of such buildings, the Colonial Government conferred a sort of negative easement on the Military Authorities in respect of Crown lands, but that is not a right of user, much less a right of perpetual user.

On the contrary, it would appear that it was intended that if, at any later date, the defence requirements no longer necessitated the stoppage of building operations, the restrictions against building should cease.

It appears to this Government that the Military Authorities have lost sight of the distinction between Colonial Military lands proper and land which is referred to generally as the Military Reserve.

Having stated the views on the subject, I should be obliged if the Military Authorities would similarly place on record the grounds on which they claim a right of perpetual user over the whole of the land referred to as the "Military Reserve."

I have already, as I informed Your Excellency in letter No. 136/2 of the 10th November, referred the question to the Secretary of State for Colonies, but have not yet received a reply to my dispatch.

I have, etc.,
William Robinson,
Major-General W. Black, R.A.

Edit History

2026-05-28 20:28:20 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
The Colonial Government is not aware that such a right has ever been conferred. It is true that upon representation by the Military Authorities, the defence requirements of certain batteries rendered further building in certain localities most undesirable. It may be contended that in agreeing to permit the erection of such buildings, the Colonial Government conferred a sort of negative easement on the Military Authorities in respect of Crown lands, but that is not a right of user, much less a right of perpetual user. On the contrary, it would appear that it was intended that if, at any later date, the defence requirements no longer necessitated the stoppage of building operations, the restrictions against building should cease. It appears to this Government that the Military Authorities have lost sight of the distinction between Colonial Military lands proper and land which is referred to generally as the Military Reserve. Having stated the views on the subject, I should be obliged if the Military Authorities would similarly place on record the grounds on which they claim a right of perpetual user over the whole of the land referred to as the "Military Reserve." I have already, as I informed Your Excellency in letter No. 136/2 of the 10th November, referred the question to the Secretary of State for Colonies, but have not yet received a reply to my dispatch. I have, etc., William Robinson, Major-General W. Black, R.A.
Baseline (Original)
The Colonial Government is not aware that such a right has ever been con -ferred. It is true that upon represi... The Military Authorities. Jation by that the defence requirements of certain batteries rendered further building in certain localities most under rable. teed not agreed the Colonial Government ag to permit the erection of such buildings It may 20 doing may be contended that in the Colonial Government conferred eavement прог Authoritice in respect of a sort of negative the Military Authoritice ench lands, but that is not a right τι asdtr. On the corp of user" much less a right of perpetual otary it would appear that it was intended that if, at an any later date, the defence requirementi 200 longer newssitated the stoppage of -building operations, the restrictions against building should cease. It appears to this Government that the Military Authorities have lost sight 547 sight of the distinction behien Co. Zonial Military lands proper and land which is referred to generally as the Military Reverse. Staving the stated the vicios on the subject, sent on of this Government I should be obliged if the Military Authorities would similarly place cu rounds on which they record the grounds claim a right of perpetual ever over the whole of the land referred & ar The "Military Reserve." my I have already, as I u w I informed Your Excellency Zetter Ni 136/2 of the 10th November, referred the quest. ion to the Secretary of State for Colonies, but have not yet received This Excellency. reply to my my dispatch. I have yo Ke Je William Robison. -Major éjeneral IV. Black, B.
2026-05-28 20:28:20 · Baseline
View content

The Colonial Government is not aware that such a right has ever been con -ferred. It is true that upon represi... The Military

Authorities.

Jation

by that the defence requirements of certain batteries rendered further building in certain localities most under rable.

teed not

agreed

the Colonial Government ag to permit the erection of such buildings

It may

20

doing

may be contended that in the Colonial Government conferred

eavement

прог Authoritice in respect of

a sort of negative the Military Authoritice

ench lands, but that is not a right

τι

asdtr.

On the corp

of user" much less a right of perpetual

otary it would appear that it was intended that if, at an

any later date, the defence requirementi

200

longer newssitated the stoppage of -building operations, the restrictions

against building should cease.

It appears to this Government that the Military Authorities have lost

sight

547

sight of the distinction behien Co. Zonial Military lands proper and land which is referred to generally as the Military

Reverse.

Staving the stated the vicios on the subject,

sent on

of this Government

I should be obliged if the Military Authorities would similarly place cu

rounds on which they

record the

grounds

claim a right of perpetual ever over the whole of the land referred & ar The "Military

Reserve."

my

I have already, as I u

w I informed Your Excellency Zetter Ni 136/2 of the 10th November, referred the quest. ion to the Secretary of State for Colonies, but have not yet received

This Excellency.

reply to my

my dispatch.

I have yo

Ke

Je William Robison.

-Major éjeneral IV. Black, B.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.